“History doesn’t repeat itself, but it does rhyme.”
— Mark Twain

To all those who read and write China books – Something worth pondering from Ellen LaMotte

Posted: September 15th, 2013 | 3 Comments »

American Ellen Newbold LaMotte arrived in Peking in 1916 after a period as a nurse on the European front in WW1. After several visits over several years to the then capital of China during the years of the war she penned a gossipy and interesting snapshot of the city at the time – Peking Dust (free here on Project Gutenberg to download) – in 1919. The opening paragraphs may give a little pause for thought for readers AND writers of China books (your blogger here included!)….

cover

“Two classes of books are written about China by two classes of people. There are books written by people who have spent the night in China, as it were, superficial and amusing, full of the tinkling of temple bells; and there are other books written by people who have spent years in China and who know it well, – ponderous books, full of absolute information, heavy and unreadable.

Books of the first class get one nowhere. They are delightful and entertaining, but one feels their irresponsible authorship. Books of the second class get one nowhere, for one cannot read them; they are too didactic and dull. The only people who might read them do not read them, for they are possessed of deep, fundamental knowledge of China, and their views agree in no slightest particular with the views set forth by the learned scholars and theorists.”

index

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

3 Comments on “To all those who read and write China books – Something worth pondering from Ellen LaMotte”

  1. 1 Bob Rust said at 10:05 pm on September 15th, 2013:

    I wonder whether some words were omitted from the last quoted sentence.

  2. 2 Paul French said at 11:50 pm on September 15th, 2013:

    Well spotted! missing few words added now

  3. 3 Rachel Kasumba said at 3:55 pm on September 19th, 2013:

    Ms. LaMotte’s 1919 analysis above certainly rung true at the time. Today, with increased communication and competition due to technology, briefcase voyagers have little place to thrive. The internet has opened up space and freedom for all to question assumptions and conclusions, hence forcing would-be and current “opinion leaders” and “experts”, to spend actual time researching their fields, etc.


Leave a Reply